Reddit Users Weigh In on Upstate New York’s Most Underwhelming Landscapes

While Upstate New York is often celebrated for its rolling hills, pristine lakes, and vibrant forests, a recent online discussion revealed that not everyone views the region’s counties through rose-colored glasses.

In a recent post on the r/UpstateNewYork subreddit, one user sparked debate by asking a provocative question: "What’s the least scenic county in Upstate New York?" The topic quickly gained traction, prompting hundreds of replies as Redditors shared their honest, and often blunt, thoughts.

Though opinions varied wildly, three counties emerged as frequent targets in the thread. It’s important to note that while some commenters were quick to criticize certain areas, others passionately defended their hometowns, underscoring the subjective nature of what qualifies as "beautiful."

Still, based on recurring mentions, upvotes, and general tone, here’s a breakdown of the Top 3 Counties Considered Least Scenic in Upstate New York, as determined by Reddit’s candid community.

#3 – Wayne County (Key Communities of Newark, Palmyra, Sodus)

Wayne County was often described as "monotonous" by commenters, largely due to its flat terrain and agricultural sprawl. While some users acknowledged scenic views near Lake Ontario, much of the inland area was referred to as "forgettable."

Reddit says: “Not ugly, just kind of… uninspiring unless you’re into cornfields.”

#2 – Orleans County (Key Communities of Medina, Albion, Holley)

This small county west of Rochester didn’t escape criticism either. Many Reddit users felt Orleans lacked defining natural features beyond the Erie Canal.

Despite the charm of historic towns like Medina, some found the county underwhelming overall.

Reddit says: “Other than a few nice spots, it’s just there. Doesn’t stand out.”

#1 – Genesee County (Key Communities of Batavia, Le Roy, Pembroke)

Topping the list was Genesee County which many dubbed the "most forgettable" part of Upstate. Critics cited its flat, featureless landscape and the absence of major lakes, mountains, or unique landmarks.

Reddit says: “It’s not ugly, it’s just plain. You pass through and don’t remember it.”

Despite the playful jabs, the thread’s overall tone trended toward light-hearted debate rather than harsh critique. Many users emphasized that even the so-called "least scenic" counties still hold charm, whether in small-town warmth, historical sites, or peaceful farmland views.

As one commenter put it best, “There’s no ‘ugly’ in Upstate New York - just places you have to look a little harder to appreciate.”

Disclaimer: The opinions shared in this article do not reflect the views of Niagara Action.

Reddit Users Weigh In on Upstate New York’s Most Underwhelming Landscapes