Governor Kathy Hochul is proposing a significant reshaping of Niagara Falls State Park with plans to bring Whirlpool State Park and Devil’s Hole State Park under the same umbrella in an effort to spread tourism beyond the Falls. The idea, she said, is to encourage visitors to stay longer in the region. The proposal, outlined in Hochul’s State of the State booklet released Tuesday, comes as state data continues to show a stark imbalance in where tourists spend their time. Niagara Falls State Park attracts roughly 9 million visitors each year, while nearby attractions just outside its boundaries draw a fraction of that number. The Aquarium of Niagara, for example, sees slightly more than 200,000 visitors annually despite being only steps away from the park’s northern edge. Tour groups and individual travelers tend to cluster around iconic attractions such as Goat Island, the Maid of the Mist boat tour, and the Cave of the Winds, leaving other attractions and experiences overlooked. This is in sharp contrast to the Canadian side of the falls where the attractions on Clifton Hill were strategically placed to benefit directly from the falls and do so at a high rate. Her State of the State booklet describes the plan as a way to create a “seamless corridor of breathtaking overlooks, historic sites and world-class hiking opportunities.” The governor’s office says the goal is to better connect visitors to destinations such as the Aquarium of Niagara and the Underground Railroad Heritage Center, which sits roughly midway between Niagara Falls State Park and Whirlpool State Park. The proposal would extend Niagara Falls State Park northward along the eastern shore of the Niagara River, effectively linking three parks that already form a roughly five-mile vertical line along the gorge. Niagara Falls State Park sits at the southern end where the river makes its dramatic turn over the Falls. Whirlpool State Park lies about two and a half miles north and Devil’s Hole is another mile and a half beyond that. Both Whirlpool and Devil’s Hole are known for breathtaking views of the Niagara Gorge, steep stairways to the river’s edge, and close-up views of the Niagara rapids. According to the governor’s office, the expanded park footprint would add approximately two miles of multi-use hiking trails and improve access to natural and cultural attractions. Officials say the changes are intended to “promote longer tourism stays” and increase visitor spending. “As a native of Western New York, no one understands the majesty of Niagara Falls and its economic impact as a world-class tourist destination more than I do,” Hochul said. “This will benefit not just those who visit, but all Western New York residents by creating a seamless corridor of breathtaking overlooks, historic sites, and world-class hiking opportunities.” Although the park consolidation is part of Hochul’s broader 2026 agenda, she did not mention it directly during her State of the State address. What the idea does not address, however, is the lack of excitement that currently exists among the New York side of the falls in terms of attractions for tourists to experience. Compared to the Canadian side of the falls, it is sorely lacking. Expanding Niagara Falls State Park along the Niagara Gorge along empty unoccupied space would simply exacerbate an already glaring problem. Niagara Falls State Park, established in 1885 as the first state park in New York, spans roughly 400 acres and was the most visited state park in New York in 2024, drawing more than 9.5 million visitors. Tourism remains a major economic driver in the region; visitors to Niagara County spent an estimated $1.163 billion in 2024 and the tourism industry accounted for more than 22% of the county’s workforce. The park hosts major attractions such as the Maid of the Mist, Cave of the Winds, the Niagara Scenic Trolley, and the 230-foot Observation Tower. Whirlpool State Park, which opened in 1928, covers 109 acres overlooking the Niagara Whirlpool and recorded 453,643 visitors in 2024. Devil’s Hole State Park, established in 1924, encompasses 42 acres near Niagara University and the Niagara Power Project and drew 357,807 visitors last year. Both parks currently offer free access. Promotional Content Hochul Proposes Expanding Niagara Falls State Park to Encompass Whirlpool, Devil’s Hole

Local businessman, community leader and Niagara Falls Board of Education member Russ Petrozzi today announced he will run for Niagara County Legislator this November in the 5th district. The seat is currently held by Legislator Chris Robins, who announced he will not seek re-election. Petrozzi plans to seek the Republican and Conservative lines. “I have a long career in serving this community and I want to continue doing that as a legislator where I think I can have a significant, positive impact for the people of Niagara Falls and the Town of Niagara,” said Petrozzi.  “Chris Robins is a good friend and has done a great job for our community.  I would like to continue that.” Petrozzi is the long-time Vice President of Capitol Cleaners, a company founded by his family.  The company is long-known for its community involvement, in particular the “Coats 4 Kids” campaign it ran each year.  Petrozzi has also served on a Niagara Falls Board of Education, having first been elected in 2000.  He has served on numerous community boards including the Niagara USA Chamber and Empower Niagara (formerly United Cerebral Palsy Association of Niagara County) and received several awards for his efforts. “I love this community and have dedicated much of my life to trying to make it better,” said Petrozzi.  “I want to serve in the Legislature because local government is about working together to get things done, not partisanship.  Legislator Robins is a Democrat and I am a Republican but we share a very similar approach to government and the issues.” Petrozzi said if elected he wants to explore ways to strengthen the ties between county government and localities in a way that results in equal or better services at lower costs. He also wants to be part of the county’s efforts on brownfield revitalization to turn former industrial sites back to productive use. “As a small businessman, I know firsthand how the affordability crisis is impacting the community and the fact is we cannot ask people to keep paying more,” said Petrozzi.  “We need to look for new ways to deliver for taxpayers and we need to grow our tax base.  That has to be our focus.” Promotional Content Local Businessman and Community Leader Russ Petrozzi Announces Run for County Legislator

A "Niagara Falls man" wounded in an early morning shooting on the New York State Thruway remains at the center of an investigation filled with bizarre statements and unanswered questions as law enforcement pieces together what actually happened. Niagara Action was first to identify the shooting  victim as 32-year-old Dante Richardson, a former failed legislative candidate for the Niagara County Legislature. Richardson suffered multiple gunshot wounds to his legs and has since been released from the hospital. The shooting occurred shortly after midnight as Richardson was driving northbound on the I-190. He was operating a Chevy Impala with a female passenger seated in the front, referred to as his girlfriend. At some point between the Vulcan Street and Sheridan Drive/Kenmore Avenue exits a dark-colored vehicle reportedly pulled alongside Richardson’s car and fired multiple shots into the driver’s side door of Richardson's vehicle. According to sources, Richardson and his passengers were on their way home from a bar. It is unknown if Richardson was intoxicated. Investigators documented three bullet holes along the left side of the Impala, including two rounds that entered below the driver’s side door handle and another penetrating near the front edge of the rear driver’s side door. Richardson was struck multiple times in the legs. Richardson later told authorities that he began losing sensation in his legs at which point his girlfriend climbed over him to continue driving the car toward Niagara Falls. During that time, 911 was called to report the shooting. However, this information has already prompted suspicion due to the space available for two people to fit on the driver’s side of the vehicle as Richardson allegedly never moved. Niagara Falls police officers were already at the hospital when the Impala arrived around 1am. Officers encountered Richardson and two passengers, neither of whom were injured. Hospital staff brought Richardson inside for treatment. He was later transferred by ambulance to Erie County Medical Center. Before New York State troopers arrived, Niagara Falls police secured Richardson’s vehicle and noted the visible bullet damage. A bullet was also recovered from the roadway near the car. The vehicle and evidence were later turned over to the New York State Police Bureau of Criminal Investigation who have assumed control of the case. Once at Niagara Falls Memorial Medical Center, Richardson reportedly refused to cooperate with law enforcement and told them to leave-a questionable decision for someone who purports to be the victim of a crime. However, this is not surprising given Richardson’s history with law enforcement. In 2014, he was convicted in Erie County Court of first-degree burglary, first-degree robbery, and second-degree criminal possession of a weapon for a violent home invasion that occurred in Buffalo in 2012. He is considered a violent felon under New York's penal code. Prosecutors alleged the home invasion was both calculated and violent. Once inside the home wearing masks and armed with a loaded .32 caliber pistol, Richardson and his accomplice Wielbon repeatedly threatened the victim’s life while demanding money. One allegation was that the gun was forced into the woman's mouth, breaking at least one of her teeth. Richardson fled the residence when Buffalo Police arrived, escaping $10 in cash and a bag of condoms. On April 4th, 2014, Judge Case sentenced him to 10 years in state prison. Richardson ultimately served eight years of that sentence before being  released on parole, where he remained under supervision until 2023. In their press release, the Erie County District Attorney’s Office joked that after Richardson’s trial the jury, “quickly saw through the defendant’s lies, as evidenced by their 1½ hours of deliberations, which included lunch.” As of now, the New York State Police Bureau of Criminal Investigation continues to examine physical evidence, review surveillance and traffic data, and interview any potential witnesses. No arrests have been made at this time. For now, the shooting has left more questions than answers. Promotional Content Violent Felon Dante Richardson Refuses to Cooperate with Police After Curious Shooting

Niagara Falls police assisted New York State Police early Monday morning after a gunshot victim drove to Niagara Falls Memorial Medical Center (NFMMC) under circumstances that investigators are still working to clarify. Niagara Falls Police were alerted around 1am after a 911 caller reported they were en route to the hospital with a shooting victim following an incident on the New York State Thruway. State troopers were also dispatched to the hospital in response due to the location of the incident. Officers encountered a Chevy Impala stopped outside the hospital and made contact with the male driver, who had suffered gunshot wounds, along with two passengers who were uninjured. Hospital staff brought the driver inside for treatment. The victim has been identified as 32-year-old Dante Richardson. Police said the driver had been shot at multiple times and sustained serious but non-life-threatening injuries. He was later transported by ambulance to Erie County Medical Center for additional care. Before state troopers arrived, Niagara Falls officers secured the vehicle and noted three visible bullet holes along the driver’s side. A projectile was also found in the roadway near the car. Preliminary information provided to police indicates the vehicle was traveling on the Thruway in the Buffalo area when gunfire struck the car with rounds piercing the door and hitting the driver on the left side of his body. The shooting occurred between the Vulcan Street exit and the Sheridan Drive/Kenmore Avenue exit according to a New York State Troopers news release. A vehicle pulled up next to the victim's Malibu and fired multiple shots, at least one of which hit Richardson. He then continued driving to NFMMC. According to a law enforcement source, the driver and both passengers reportedly had left a bar and were traveling to Niagara Falls when the incident occurred. However, many questions remain unanswered as to the circumstances surrounding the incident. The New York State Police Bureau of Criminal Investigation has taken over the case. A motive for the incident remains unclear. Promotional Content Failed Niagara County Legislative Candidate Dante Richardson Shot Driving Home from Bar

On January 8th 2026 at 2246 hours, The Niagara County Sheriff’s Office responded to reports of damaged property in the 6600 block of Royal Parkway South in the Town of Lockport. Shortly after that, Deputies were dispatched to the 100 block of Whispering Pines Drive for the same. Deputies found that for two consecutive nights numerous cars and homes were being egged throughout the Town of Lockport. Egg cartons and other evidence were discarded on the streets and upwards of Twenty (20) homeowners reported damaged their homes and/or vehicles. Neighborhoods included were Royal Parkway South, Village Parkway, Harvest Ridge Way, Jim Kelly Drive, Whispering Pines Drive and Forest Hill Drive.   An investigation led to the arrest of John K. Taylor, an 18-year-old male, Benjamin B. Mckenzie, a 19-year-old male, Peter J. Blake an 18-year-old male and Cain D. Smeal an 18-year-old male, all from the Town of Newfane. They are charged with Criminal Mischief 4th (Misdemeanor) and multiple counts of Criminal Tampering 3rd. (Misdemeanor), and released on Appearance Tickets. Further charges are pending as Deputies continue to follow up with numerous residents. Promotional Content Dozens of Homes, Vehicles Egged in Niagara County Leads to Arrests

Stock Photo LISTEN TO POLICE AUDIO BELOW Law enforcement observed a male in a red tracksuit walking west on Walnut towards 20th Street who, upon observing police, began running, around 10:30pm on January 2nd in Niagara Falls. He was said to be clutching his waistband. Officers engaged in a chase with the suspect who matched the description from a robbery that occurred shortly beforehand. Police yelled for the suspect to stop, but he did not comply. He began playing with what was in his waistband. All units were called to the location. Supervisors were called to the location for force being used to subdue the suspect. He was placed in custody after use of force. It is unknown if either the suspect or police sustained injuries during the struggle. No further information is available at this time. These are merely allegations and should not be taken as fact. LISTEN TO FULL AUDIO HERE: Promotional Content Listen as Niagara Falls Police Apprehend Dangerous Robbery Suspect by Force

LISTEN TO POLICE AUDIO BELOW Law enforcement received a call around 9am on January 5th after reports of an assault on Hyde Park Boulevard. The 911 caller - a third party - stated that Robert McClain punched a woman in the face. He is a cab driver who would not drive away due to the argument, which was taking place outside. Police responded to the scene. It is unknown if the male was arrested. No further information is available at this time. These are merely allegations and should not be taken as fact. LISTEN TO FULL AUDIO HERE: Promotional Content Cab Driver Witnesses Woman's Face Destroyed During Niagara Falls Assault

LISTEN TO POLICE AUDIO BELOW INCLUDING FEMALE OFFICER On January 9, 2026, at approximately 12:30 am, The Niagara Falls Police Department Crash Investigation Unit responded to the intersection of 16 th Street and Cleveland Avenue to investigate a two-vehicle crash involving a marked police cruiser.   A 2014 Ford Fusion, operated by a 49-year-old Niagara Falls man, was traveling north on 16th St., disregarded the stop sign and struck a 2016 Ford Taurus police vehicle that was traveling east on Cleveland Avenue. The impact of the crash spun the police vehicle around. The Ford Fusion struck a telephone pole on the northeast corner of the intersection before striking a parked and unoccupied 2010 Ford F150 truck.   The Ford Fusion was occupied by four people. The male driver and 2 female passengers were taken to ECMC, where they are being treated for apparently non-life-threatening injuries. A male passenger in the vehicle was taken to Niagara Falls Memorial Medical Center, where he is being evaluated. The female officer was also taken to Niagara Falls Memorial Medical Center, where she was treated and released for minor head and leg injuries. The driver of the Ford Fusion was arrested for Criminal Possession of a Weapon. Additional charges are pending. The male passenger was arrested for an outstanding warrant for Felony narcotics possession and intent to sell. Police audio at the time of the accident provided additional details, including that multiple passengers of the Ford Fusion were unresponsive after the crash. LISTEN TO FULL AUDIO HERE: Promotional Content Niagara Falls Officer Struck by Vehicle and Hospitalized, Other Passengers Unresponsive

A Niagara Falls serial killer already convicted in multiple murders has now been tied to a fourth killing—one that has remained unresolved for nearly half a century. Police say Richard Fox, now 62, admitted last year that he killed his grandmother, Beatrice Meabon, at her home on Cain Road in the Town of Brant in 1976, when he was just 13-years-old. Authorities said Meabon was found stabbed inside her home in July 1976 and later died at a hospital. At the time, her death was deemed suspicious, but no arrest was ever made. Fox’s confession surfaced during an expanding homicide investigation that has already connected him to the murders of multiple women across Western New York spanning decades. Police said that as investigators reviewed historic case files and re-interviewed surviving witnesses, they discovered Meabon was Fox’s grandmother and confirmed he had been present at her home on the day she was stabbed. Fox later admitted responsibility for her death. Because Fox was a juvenile at the time and laws in place back in 1976, prosecutors say he cannot be criminally charged in Meabon’s killing. “Although no charges will be filed regarding the murder of Mrs. Meabon, the victim, family and public deserve the truth of what happened 49 years ago,” Brant police said in a statement. “Law enforcement is committed to pursuing justice and holding those accountable, no matter how great the passage of time.” Fox was arrested in January 2025 after investigators linked him to the murders of Marquita Mull and Cassandra Watson, two Buffalo women who disappeared decades apart. Police said Fox admitted to killing both and leaving their bodies off the Chautauqua Rails to Trails path in the Town of Portland. On Monday, December 22nd, Niagara County District Attorney Brian D. Seaman announced an indictment charging Fox Murdering 32-year-old Crystal Curthoys in January 2023, in Niagara Falls. Promotional Content Niagara Falls Serial Killer Linked to Fourth Murder, Killed Grandma when he was Child

A New York Supreme Court Judge issued a sweeping decision this morning dismissing a lawsuit brought by 27 restaurants against Buffalo Biodiesel, rejecting what the court characterized as speculative, conclusory, and legally deficient claims. The rebuke lands squarely on the shoulders of plaintiffs’ counsel, Manhattan attorney Michael Collesano. In a detailed Memorandum Decision, Hon. Michael A. Siragusa, J.S.C., granted Buffalo Biodiesel's motion to dismiss finding that the action should never have been filed in the first place. The court concluded that the lawsuit was barred because it duplicated more than two dozen already-pending cases, failed to plead basic elements of antitrust and fraud claims, and relied on allegations contradicted by evidence and unsupported by facts. At issue in the case is Buffalo Biodiesel, a Buffalo-based business operating in the Northeastern U.S. with over 28,000 suppliers who collect used cooking oil, that sued 27 restaurants who breached contracts for the collection of waste vegetable cooking oil purchase agreements in Erie County Supreme Court. All 27 of those restaurants then attempted to bring a separate, omnibus action accusing Buffalo Biodiesel of fraud, monopolistic conduct, and abusive litigation tactics, all under the direction and advice of Collesano. They are now the plaintiffs in this action. Although the subject for a future story, Collesano found these clients through soliciting them through NYSCEF, which is the New York filing database. This has been the subject of grievances, motion practice, and other court filings. Collesano has recently stated that he charges each of his clients a modest sum of money – anywhere from $1,000 to $2,500 – for representation in addition to seeking a contingency fee for any monies recovered. Those familiar with the situation have referred to it as a scheme to increase numbers while providing minimal representation. A grievance has reportedly been filed regarding this issue with the eighth judicial district against Collesano. Collesano and his clients claimed Buffalo Biodiesel filed those related actions “for the primary purpose of enforcing and maintaining its market share,” using what they described as “oppressive litigation against a relatively small damages claim to force settlement and continued business with distant small businesses.” The court disagreed. Judge Siragusa wrote, “the record (primarily, Plaintiffs’ own allegations and exhibits) establishes the Related Actions are the quintessential ‘other action[s] pending between the same parties for the same cause of action in a court of any state …’ (CPLR 3211(a)(5)).” “As such,” the court ruled, “[] the motion to dismiss shall be granted.” In other words, Collesano attempted an end run around dozens of existing cases by filing a new lawsuit that duplicated them. The CPLR expressly prohibit that maneuver. CLICK TO READ PDF DECISION HERE The contract signed by each restaurant, or "Exclusive Waste Vegetable Cooking Oil Purchase & Sale Agreements" as it is referred to by Buffalo Biodiesel, required restaurants to provide all waste vegetable cooking oil exclusively to the company for a 5-year term, automatically renewing unless notice was given to cancel. Buffalo Biodiesel supplied containers, collected the oil, and processed it at a facility in Tonawanda, New York. This was all laid out clearly, in black and white, signed, initialed, and with copies provided to the supplier. Buffalo Biodiesel alleges that the plaintiffs breached those contracts by supplying oil to competitors or various other forms of breaches. Rather than confront those claims directly, the plaintiffs accused Buffalo Biodiesel of not collecting oil, misrepresentations, and etc.. Judge Siragusa rejected all of plaintiffs' allegations outright. The court emphasized that while it must ordinarily accept pleaded facts as true, it is “not required to accept factual allegations, or accord Plaintiffs’ favorable inferences, in those cases where the factual assertions are ‘inherently incredible or flatly contradicted by documentary evidence.’” Plaintiffs also alleged that Buffalo Biodiesel violated General Business Law § 340 – the Donnelly Act – by restraining trade and monopolizing the used cooking oil market. Judge Siragusa. “A plaintiff alleging a claim under GBL Section 340 must identify the relevant product market, allege a conspiracy between two or more entities (that are actually competitors), and allege that the economic impact of that conspiracy was to restrain trade in the relevant market," the court explained. According to Siragusa, Collesano did none of that. “Plaintiffs’ bare bones, conclusory allegations,” the decision states, “(based almost entirely ‘upon information and belief’ without a scintilla of reference to the bases for same) fail to identify a single individual or entity ‘in competition’ with Defendant, much less that such unidentified individual or entity engaged in a conspiracy with Defendant.” In short, the antitrust claim collapsed because it was speculation masquerading as law. The court was equally blunt in rejecting plaintiffs’ fraud and misrepresentation claims. “To allege a cause of action based on fraud,” Siragusa wrote, a plaintiff must plead a false representation, knowledge of falsity, intent to induce reliance, justifiable reliance, and damages. “Here, the alleged fraud is based on the same allegations as Plaintiffs’ breach of contract claim and thus is duplicative of that cause of action," concluded the court. The plaintiffs also “failed to allege fraud with the requisite particularity (CPLR 3016(b)).” The result was total defeat for Collesano and his clients. Collesano had attempted twice to consolidate all 27 related actions, stay discovery, and amend counterclaims. Those efforts failed as well, with a previous judge refusing to even sign an order to show cause. Buffalo Biodiesel's motion requested the court impose $10,000 in sanctions from Collesano as a punishment for his frivolous conduct. Siragusa declined to impose them. According to a source, Collesano's conduct has caused havoc in dozens of proceedings involving Buffalo Biodiesel including, but not limited to, interfering with a default, not complying with ordered discovery, not complying with ordered mediation, court outbursts, ex parte communication with the court, and most recently an admission on the record that he was hired by a competitor of Buffalo Biodesel, which raises all sorts of concerns including collusion, conspiracy, tortious interference of contract, and more. In a comment from a source to Niagara Action given after this article was published, during the previously mentioned proceeding where he sought and was denied class action certification Collesano purportedly "put on a parlor show" by bringing people into the courtroom who looked like "disheveled street people." The source told Niagara Action, "they looked as though Collesano gave each $20 to sit there and pretend to be his office staff." If that is the case, the incident likely warrants being investigated by the Eighth Judicial District as being a fraud on the court. With all this in mind, the decision might not have gone far enough to prevent this conduct from continuing in the future. However, a review of Collesano's financial situation might have played into such a decision. Just months prior, a decision by the Hon. Deborah Chimes rejected Collesano's efforts to certify a class action against Buffalo Biodiesel because of "evidence submitted [] not sufficiently address[ing] or satisfy[ing] [] factors" including financial resources available to prosecute the action. In many ways Erie County Supreme Court is being held hostage by Collesano through his conduct. He has levied multiple complaints against judges that have ruled against him, becoming so serious according to our source that the New York Attorney General became involved. This decision will undoubtedly result in more litigation based on Collesano's own modus operandi and personal vendetta against Buffalo Biodiesel, which is evidence based on most filings — most hundreds of pages repeating the same theories over and over again that read as personal grievances. Attorney Michael Collesano The dismissal adds to a growing list of recent headlines involving Collesano including a defamation lawsuit against a neighbor for comments allegedly made about his manhood and a foreclosure action of his Manhattan home. In the defamation lawsuit, filed on May 11th, 2025, Collesano alleged that Aimee Fink, a neighbor in his condominium complex, launched a campaign to damage his professional reputation and business. The verified complaint chronicled what Collesano described as months of harassment tied to a contentious board election at the Warren House condominium and accused Fink of making defamatory statements, interfering with his business dealings, and disparaging him personally and professionally. However, the heart of his lawsuit centers around a comment levied on January 17th, 2025, where Fink allegedly motioned with her fingers to indicate something small and shouted: “you have a little dick.” Collesano claims the insult was made publicly, witnessed by building staff, and illustrative of a broader campaign of harassment. Niagara Action has not independently verified the claims made in this lawsuit and presents them solely as allegations, which remain unproven unless and until established in court. Two weeks after the January lobby incident, Collesano says he told Fink he intended to sue her. According to the filing, she responded by thrusting her middle finger in his face and calling police. The episode generated an NYPD report but no criminal charges. In September 2025 the Board of Managers of The Warren House Condominium filed suit in the Supreme Court of New York County against attorney Collesano, his wife Mandy Collesano, and PNC Bank, N.A. The action seeks to foreclose a lien against Unit 11F where Collesano both resides and purportedly operates his law practice. According to the verified complaint filed by the Board, Collesano fell significantly behind on his financial obligations to the condominium. As a unit owner, he was required to pay common charges of $981.51 per month, an additional $65 monthly storage fee, and special assessments in the amounts of $285.07 and $1,318.68. According to the complaint, these charges are not optional and they were expressly required under the building’s Declaration, By-Laws, and the New York Condominium Act. The Board alleges that Collesano failed to make the required payments and allowed arrears to accumulate to $18,791.35 as of January 1st, 2025, resulting in a lien being recorded in February 2025. Although he later made a lump-sum payment of $25,000 in April, the lien remained unsatisfied and charges continued to accrue. By the time the lawsuit was filed, Collesano allegedly owed an additional $18,778.53 in unpaid common charges and assessments. The complaint seeks not only recovery of arrears but also foreclosure of the lien on Collesano’s unit. His wife is named to ensure any tenancy rights are terminated while PNC Bank is named because it holds a $125,000 second mortgage that would be wiped out. The unit is further encumbered by a $630,000 first mortgage held by the First National Bank of Long Island. In addition, the Board is requesting the appointment of a receiver to collect rent, reimbursement of sums it may advance for taxes or insurance, and attorneys’ fees projected at $30,000 or more. If successful, the action would result in the sale of Collesano’s unit at auction. Public records show Collesano also has a history of tax liens and financial encumbrances tied to him. These include a $38,847.43 federal tax lien filed in 2009, a $7,307.89 federal tax lien filed in 2010, and a $5,510.49 federal tax lien filed in 2011, along with additional liens recorded through at least 2015, some later released. Collesano is also involved in a defamation case. In May 2025, he and his company, NYC Property Expo, Inc., which also purportedly operates out of his Warren House unit along with his legal practice, filed suit against Elegran LLC and Aimee Fink, a neighbor in the Warren House. Promotional Content Judge Dismisses Lawsuit Against Buffalo Biodiesel Brought by Customers, Embarrasses their Attorney

LISTEN TO POLICE AUDIO BELOW Law enforcement received a call around 6:30pm on January 6th after reports of a motor vehicle v. pedestrian accident with injuries that occurred in the area of Genesee Street and Jefferson Avenue in Buffalo. The 911 call said that a female was struck and lying in the road. EMS and emergency personnel was called to the scene. According to witnesses at the location, the woman could be heard moaning "help me," but could not move any part of her body. She was bleeding. Police responded to the scene. She was transported to a local hospital for treatment. No further information is available at this time. These are merely allegations and should not be taken as fact. LISTEN TO FULL AUDIO HERE: Promotional Content Woman Hit by Vehicle Lies Motionless, Bleeding in Road Moaning for Help

LISTEN TO POLICE AUDIO BELOW Law enforcement received a call around 5:20am on January 7th after reports of a domestic incident with injuries on the 300 block of Oliver Street in North Tonawanda. The 911 caller and victim said that a male punched her in the face "several times" and requested an ambulance for emergency response. The male suspect was identified as a Kuron (spelling not exact) Thomas. When police were called, Thomas was said to be fleeing the location is a blue jacket. She also told police that he strangled her. During the call she was heard screaming in the background, evidencing that he was still there. Police responded to the scene. It is unknown if the male was apprehended. The female received medical treatment, but NA does not have information regarding whether she was hospitalized. No further information is available at this time. These are merely allegations and should not be taken as fact. LISTEN TO FULL AUDIO HERE: Promotional Content Woman Seriously Injured After Repeated Blows to the Face, Strangled in North Tonawanda

A Niagara County Court judge is expected to decide by the end of January whether a woman convicted of a fatal stabbing should receive a reduced prison sentence under New York’s Domestic Violence Survivors Justice Act. Judge John Ottaviano is reviewing final written submissions filed December 29th by both prosecutors and defense attorneys for Ashley Berger, 42, of Niagara Falls. Berger has already served roughly 10 years out of a 15-year state prison sentence stemming from the killing of 22-year-old Richard Christian. She is seeking either a shortened sentence or immediate release. The underlying crime dates back to April 27th, 2014, when Niagara Falls Police responded to the Rodeway Inn Motel on Main Street. Officers found Christian suffering from a single stab wound to the chest outside a motel room door. He was taken to Niagara Falls Memorial Medical Center where he ultimately died. Investigators determined that Berger had been staying at the motel and that Christian had solicited her as a prostitute. As part of a plea to first-degree manslaughter, she admitted stabbing Christian during a dispute after he attempted to reclaim the $100 he had paid her. Berger said that the incident took place after Christian refused to put on a condom and had forced himself on her. Berger was a 31-year-old mother of two with no prior criminal record. The request followed more than three days of testimony in October during which Berger and multiple expert witnesses detailed allegations of long-term abuse, exploitation, and coercion. Ottaviano is evaluating the request under the Domestic Violence Survivors Justice Act, enacted in 2019, which allows courts to reconsider sentences when abuse is shown to have played a substantial role in the underlying crime. The statute applies to both pending cases and post-conviction resentencing motions. Expert testimony presented on Berger’s behalf included analysis from professionals specializing in domestic violence, trauma, and sex trafficking. One of the experts has previously testified in nationally prominent sexual assault cases, lending additional weight to the defense’s argument that Berger’s actions occurred within a broader pattern of victimization. Under the law, defendants must demonstrate that they were victims of physical, sexual, or psychological abuse at the time of the offense and that the abuse was a significant contributing factor to their criminal conduct. Prosecutors challenged Berger’s credibility during the hearing, suggesting her account had been shaped to meet the legal threshold for relief under the statute. Defense experts countered that independent evidence supported Berger’s narrative. This would be the first such relief granted in Niagara County. Promotional Content Judge Weighs Sentence Cut After Niagara Falls Woman Killed Client Over Condom, $100 Cash

LISTEN TO POLICE AUDIO BELOW Law enforcement received a call around 7:30pm on January 4th after reports of a mental health emergency on 69th Street in Niagara Falls. The 911 caller said that her 16-year-old son, who is on the spectrum, was attempting to jump out of their window, stating that he was going to cause harm to himself. Police and emergency personnel responded to the scene. It is unknown if the boy was taken for mental health treatment, but police/first responders were able to prevent the worst case scenario from occurring with a swift response. If you or someone you know is struggling with depression or suicidal thoughts, please contact the National Suicide & Crisis Lifeline at 988 for free, confidential support available 24/7. No further information is available at this time. These are merely allegations and should not be taken as fact. LISTEN TO FULL AUDIO HERE: Promotional Content Police Save 16-year-old Autistic Boy's Life in Niagara Falls who Attempted to Jump Out Window

LISTEN TO POLICE AUDIO BELOW A man died Sunday afternoon after falling from a window of a multi-story building in Lockport, police say. Police said the incident occurred around 12:15pm at a building on Main Street where a 63-year-old man fell from the eighth floor. Police audio indicated that they received a call stating a male was on the ground with blood everywhere. His identity has not been released, nor has the circumstances surrounding the fall. Emergency responders pronounced the man deceased at the scene. His body was later taken to the Erie County Medical Examiner’s Office where an autopsy will be conducted to determine the cause and manner of death. Police said the circumstances surrounding the fall remain under investigation. LISTEN TO FULL AUDIO HERE: Promotional Content Man Killed After Falling from Eighth-floor Window in Niagara County

LISTEN TO POLICE AUDIO BELOW Law enforcement received a call around 6am on January 1st after reports of a check the welfare at McDonald's on Pine Avenue in Niagara Falls. The 911 caller reported that a male in a black pickup truck appeared to be unconscious in the drive-thru line past the menu board. It is unknown what the male ordered, but Niagara Action can confirm he did not receive his food. Police responded to the scene. The male was taken into custody. No further information is available at this time. These are merely allegations and should not be taken as fact. LISTEN TO FULL AUDIO HERE: Promotional Content No Fries for You: Suspected Drunk Driver Wakes Up in McDonald's Drive-thru Line in Niagara Falls

LISTEN TO POLICE AUDIO BELOW Law enforcement received a call around 6:30pm on December 31st after repots of a home invasion in Packard Court involving two female suspects with injuries. The 911 caller said that the two females, identified as Pleasure Cox and Danasha Maxwell, broke into her home, "jumped her" causing serious injuries, and stole her daughter's black 2008 Nissan Pathfinder. The vehicle was last seen driving in the direction of Pine Avenue. Police responded to the scene. It is unknown if the vehicle was recovered, or if either women were arrested. No further information is available at this time. These are merely allegations and should not be taken as fact. LISTEN TO FULL AUDIO HERE: Promotional Content Pleasure Cox, Danasha Maxwell Seriously Injures Victim During Niagara Falls Home Invasion

LISTEN TO POLICE AUDIO BELOW Law enforcement received a call around 1:50am on December 30th after reports of a domestic incident on the 5400 block of Elm Drive in Lewiston, New York, involving injuries. The 911 caller said that his wife attacked him during a heated argument that resulted in him sustaining injuries and her fleeing the home. The husband told police that his wife stabbed him with a sharpened pencil before fleeing the home in a black Hyundai. Police responded to the scene and began a search for the wife's vehicle. It is unknown if she was found and, once she was, if an arrest was made. No further information is available at this time. These are merely allegations and should not be taken as fact. LISTEN TO FULL AUDIO HERE: Promotional Content Wife Attacks Husband and Stabs Him with a Pencil in During Niagara County Domestic

LISTEN TO POLICE AUDIO BELOW Law enforcement received a call around 10:15pm on December 30th after reports of a domestic incident on the 1300 block of East Robinson Street in North Tonawanda, New York. The first 911 caller and victim stated that his father attempted to "crush him" with a garage door. Police responded to the scene. It is unknown if the father was arrested. There was then a second male related to the incident who was stopped by police and issued tickets. This male party was reportedly verbally aggressive with police during the incident and then followed police afterward for an unknown period of time placing them in fear for their safety. No further information is available at this time. These are merely allegations and should not be taken as fact. LISTEN TO FULL AUDIO HERE: Promotional Content Son Says Father Tried to 'Crush him' with a Garage Door in North Tonawanda

LISTEN TO POLICE AUDIO BELOW Law enforcement received a call around 7:35pm on December 30th after reports of a mental health emergency at LaSalle Waterfront Park, 6611 Buffalo Avenue, in Niagara Falls, NY. Reports indicate that a male was in the area who left his jacket and phone by the gazebo at the park if he entered the water. Other than that, they had no other contact. There was no indication during the call that he was located. As previously reported, dozens of bodies travel over Niagara Falls each year that are not reported on. These bodies are discovered in various places in the lower Niagara River including, but not limited to, the Power Authority and along Lake Ontario. To be very specific, the headline is that he was feared to have entered the water and FEARED that if he did, that the body would go downstrea, due to the powerful current and travel over the falls. No further information is available at this time. These are merely allegations and should not be taken as fact. LISTEN TO FULL AUDIO HERE: Promotional Content Man Feared to Have Entered Niagara River, Body Traveled Over Niagara Falls

LISTEN TO POLICE AUDIO BELOW Law enforcement received a call around 6pm on December 30th after reports of an assault with a weapon near Mechanic Street in Wilson, New York, with injuries. The 911 caller said that a screwdriver was being used as a weapon. Medical was called to the scene in addition to law enforcement for treatment of serious injuries sustained during the incident. It was reported that both males were heavily intoxicated. One of the individual sustained lacerations along the back in addition to a stab would between the eyes from the screwdriver. Niagara County Sheriff Deputies responded to the scene. It is unknown if the male who stabbed the other male was arrested. No further information is available at this time. These are merely allegations and should not be taken as fact. LISTEN TO FULL AUDIO HERE: Promotional Content Niagara County Man Stabbed Between the Eyes with Screwdriver During Drunken Argument

New England Patriots WR Stefon Diggs is facing legal trouble after authorities brought a felony charge of strangulation and a misdemeanor assault charge stemming from an alleged incident on December 2nd, reviving scrutiny of the star receiver’s off-field conduct. A motion hearing was held Tuesday morning at Dedham District Court in Massachusetts where a judge is weighing whether to seal court records ahead of Diggs’ arraignment scheduled for January 23rd, which is just two days before the AFC Championship Game. According to WCVB-TV, the defense has asked that documents be impounded to limit public disclosure before formal proceedings begin. In a statement, the Patriots acknowledged the situation while standing behind the player. “The New England Patriots are aware of the accusations that have been made regarding Stefon Diggs. Stefon has informed the organization that he categorically denies the allegations. We support Stefon,” the team said. “We will continue to gather information and will cooperate fully with the appropriate authorities and the NFL as necessary. Out of respect for all parties involved, and given that this is an ongoing legal matter, we will have no further comment at this time.” Diggs’ legal team forcefully denied the claims. His attorney, David Meier, described the accusations as baseless and tied to a financial dispute. “Stefon Diggs categorically denies these allegations. They are unsubstantiated, uncorroborated, and were never investigated -- because they did not occur. The timing and motivation for making the allegations is crystal clear: they are the direct result of an employee-employer financial dispute that was not resolved to the employee's satisfaction. Stefon looks forward to establishing the truth in a court of law,” Meier said. According to the Boston Globe, Diggs’ lawyer Michael R. DiStefano argued that releasing details of the case could create “substantial risk of widespread publicity” that might prejudice potential jurors. The Globe also reported that Diggs’ defense team is pursuing a monetary resolution related to the dispute. The NFL confirmed it is monitoring the situation but offered no further details. “We are aware of the matter and have been in contact with the club,” the league said in a statement. “We have no further comment at this time.” Now 32, Diggs is having a strong season on the field, leading the Patriots with 82 receptions for 970 yards and four touchdowns. New England enters the final week of the regular season at 13–3 with a matchup against the Miami Dolphins before heading into the playoffs. They have a shot at claiming the number 1 seed in the AFC with a win and a Broncos loss. Promotional Content Patriots’ Stefon Diggs Hit With Felony Strangulation Charge as Legal Troubles Cloud Playoff Push

A Niagara County man who told authorities he accidentally drove onto the Lewiston-Queenston Bridge earlier this month is now being held in federal custody after investigators say the encounter uncovered drugs, cash, and a loaded firearm. Ma Le Jones, 37 from Lockport, was ordered detained following a court appearance Monday, where U.S. Magistrate Judge Jeremiah J. McCarthy ruled that he would remain in custody while facing federal drug trafficking and weapons charges. Prosecutors have charged Jones with possession with intent to distribute cocaine and possession of a firearm in furtherance of a drug trafficking crime. Federal authorities say the incident began on December 13th when Jones arrived at the Lewiston-Queenston Bridge for inspection. He presented a New York State driver’s license and told Customs and Border Protection officers that he had taken a wrong turn and was trying to re-enter the United States. During routine checks, officers discovered that Jones was subject to an active order of protection and was currently under probation supervision related to a prior firearms conviction. Based on that information, he was directed to secondary inspection. During a follow-up search, CBP officers reported finding two cell phones, $2,383 in cash, large quantities of marijuana, MDMA, cocaine, crack cocaine, and a loaded revolver. According to the U.S. Attorney’s Office, Jones remains on parole stemming from a 2017 New York State conviction for second-degree criminal possession of a weapon. Jones remains in custody. Promotional Content 'Wrong turn' at Border Results in Drug Trafficking and Firearm Arrest for Niagara County Man

State police are searching for a pickup truck driver who ran from the scene after causing a head-on collision Sunday night on the Niagara Scenic Parkway. New York State Park Police said the crash happened at approximately 8:40pm on the parkway near the 53rd Street overpass. Emergency responders from Park Police, the Niagara Falls Fire Department, and AMR were dispatched to the scene shortly afterward. Investigators said the pickup truck was traveling westbound in the eastbound lanes when it collided head-on with an SUV that was properly traveling east. The force of the impact caused significant damage to both vehicles. Before first responders arrived, the driver of the pickup truck reportedly abandoned the vehicle and fled the area on foot. Police have not released a description of the suspect and said the search remains ongoing. The driver of the SUV was transported by ambulance to a local hospital with injuries that were described as non-life-threatening. Park Police continue to investigate the crash. Anyone who has information about the fleeing driver is asked to contact law enforcement. Promotional Content Suspect Flees After Causing Head-on Collision in Niagara Falls, Victim Hospitalized with Injuries

James Glynn, longtime chairman and chief executive officer of the Maid of the Mist Corp. and one of Niagara Falls’ most influential leaders, died Sunday, December 28th, at his home following a lengthy illness. He was 91. Glynn’s association with the iconic Niagara Falls attraction spanned more than seven decades. He joined Maid of the Mist in 1950 as a ticket seller, using his earnings to help pay for his education at Niagara University. On May 25th, 1971, he realized a lifelong ambition when he purchased the company, beginning a transformative era that reshaped the historic boat tour into a world-renowned destination welcoming visitors from around the globe. Under Glynn’s leadership, the Maid of the Mist underwent significant modernization and expansion, including the launch of seven new vessels and the introduction of groundbreaking all-electric boats. On October 5th, 2020, the company placed two zero-emission, all-electric vessels into service on the Lower Niagara River—the first of their kind in the United States. Reflecting on his early days with the company during an interview with WBFO-FM, Glynn said, “My first job at the Maid was having a palm of pamphlets, and I handed them out at Prospect Point. When I gave you a pamphlet, I gave you a ticket and I asked for a dollar. The ticket was 90 cents for the boat and ten cents for the elevator.” One of the electric vessels, christened in July 2020, was named the James V. Glynn in his honor. The ceremony included a traditional mast stepping, during which a sixpence Irish coin dated 1950 was placed beneath the mast to commemorate Glynn’s first year with the company and his family’s Irish heritage. Born May 11th, 1934, in Niagara Falls, Glynn was the son of the late Vincent E. Glynn and Margaret McCarthy Glynn. He was a 1957 graduate of Niagara University having earned a bachelor’s degree in business administration. He later received an honorary doctorate of commercial science from Niagara University and a doctor of humane letters degree from St. John’s University. A Niagara University citation described him by noting, “He is, in all ways, a good man, because he thinks with his heart.” Beyond his business achievements, Glynn was widely respected for his dedication to community service and philanthropy. He spent 22 years on Niagara University’s Board of Trustees, becoming its first lay chairman and later chairman emeritus. He also chaired the 1997 Catholic Charities of Buffalo Appeal and, in 2017, Catholic Charities named its Niagara Falls facility the Glynn Family Services Center. Glynn served on the boards of numerous regional organizations, including M&T Bank, National Fuel Gas Company, Buffalo Niagara Partnership, the Niagara Falls Area Chamber of Commerce, Catholic Health, and AAA of Western & Central New York. Together with his wife Mary, Glynn supported numerous charitable efforts across Niagara County including Heart, Love & Soul, the Francis Center in Niagara Falls, and OLV Charities in Lackawanna. Under his leadership, Maid of the Mist also supported Opportunities Unlimited, United Way of Niagara Falls, Mount St. Mary’s Hospital, CARExpress Transportation Service, Summit Healthplex, and Hamilton B. Mizer Primary Care Center. The company additionally sponsors the Niagara University Vincentian Scholarship Program, the Diocese of Buffalo’s Curé of Ars dinner, and the James V. & Mary Glynn Endowment Fund for the Foundation of the Roman Catholic Diocese of Buffalo. When asked about his extensive charitable involvement, Glynn once responded, “If I don’t do it, who will?” Glynn is survived by his wife of 67 years, Mary (Gallagher) Glynn, whom he married on October 25th, 1958, at Sacred Heart Church in Niagara Falls. He is also survived by five children, 18 grandchildren, and eight great-grandchildren. He was predeceased by a grandson, James Fiore, who died in 2006, and by his brother Leo Glynn. A resident of Lewiston, Glynn was a member of St. Peter Roman Catholic Parish. His life story was captured in the book The Magic in the Mist by Linus Ormsby, which recounts a conversation between James and Mary Glynn shortly after their marriage. When Mary asked him, “Would you be happy sitting behind a desk in a law office?” Glynn replied, “I think I’ll stay at the Maid.” He never left. Promotional Content Maid of the Mist Chairman and CEO James Glynn Dies at 91

LISTEN TO POLICE AUDIO BELOW Law enforcement received a call around 11:30am on December 25th after reports of a domestic dispute at a parking lot along Kenmore Avenue in Buffalo. The 911 caller - a third party - said that a male party was attempting to run over a female with his vehicle in a parking lot. A physical description of the male was given along with the vehicle. Police responded to the scene. It is unknown if the male and/or his vehicle were located or if the female sustained any injuries during the altercation. No further information is available at this time. These are merely allegations and should not be taken as fact. LISTEN TO FULL AUDIO HERE: Promotional Content Suspect Tries to Run Over Girlfriend with Vehicle on Christmas Morning

LISTEN TO POLICE AUDIO BELOW Law enforcement received a call round 6:50pm on December 26th after reports of an assault on the 1200 block of Main Street. The 911 caller said that someone broke into his room, injected him with something and stole his debit card. It is unknown what symptoms, if any, the victim showed as a result of being injected with the unknown substance. At the time of the call, the suspect had fled. Police responded to the scene to check the welfare. No further information is available at this time. These are merely allegations and should not be taken as fact. LISTEN TO FULL AUDIO HERE: Promotional Content Suspect Injects Victim with Unknown Substance During Break-in

A third-prize Powerball ticket worth $50,000 was sold in Niagara Falls for the December 24th drawing, according to the New York Lottery. The winning ticket was purchased at the 7-Eleven located at 8505 Niagara Falls Boulevard. In total, eight third-prize Powerball tickets were sold across New York State for the Christmas Eve drawing, each matching enough numbers to secure the $50,000 prize. The remaining winning tickets were sold at the following locations: Tops at 5335 West Genesee Street in Camillus; Cortlandt Farms Cafe at 96 Oregon Road in Cortlandt Manor; a 7-Eleven at 811 Waverly Avenue in Holtsville; Islandia Expressway Inc. at 1395 Veterans Highway in Islandia; Lido Wines & Spirits Inc. at 639 East Park Avenue in Long Beach; a Gulf station at 634 Route 6 in Mahopac; and another 7-Eleven at 653 Montauk Highway in Montauk. While New York saw multiple third-prize winners, the Powerball jackpot itself, which was valued at $1.8 billion, sold to a winner in Arkansas. The holiday week also brought major lottery news elsewhere in the state. The New York Lottery announced that a winning LOTTO ticket from Wednesday’s drawing worth $13.9 million was sold at Lovely Cards and Gifts in Hicksville on Long Island. Promotional Content Third-prize Powerball Ticket Sold at Niagara Falls 7-Eleven on Christmas Eve Drawing

A Christmas Eve fire left a Hartland family without a home and killed several animals, according to authorities. The blaze broke out Tuesday night at a residence on Stone Road in Niagara County. According to the Niagara County Sheriff’s Office, the fire started in the garage shortly after 9pm and quickly spread through the rest of the house. The structure was already heavily involved by the time crews arrived. No one was inside the home when the fire started, nor were any injuries reported. However, officials believe multiple animals died in the fire. The house is considered a total loss. The Hartland Volunteer Fire Company shared information about the incident on social media, noting that the displaced family includes the department’s chaplain. In the aftermath of the fire, the American Red Cross has stepped in to assist the family with emergency needs. Investigators are continuing to examine the scene to determine what caused the fire. Promotional Content Niagara County Family Loses Home to Devastating Fire on Christmas Eve

LISTEN TO POLICE AUDIO BELOW Law enforcement received a call around 12:30pm on December 22nd regarding a medical emergency at Niagara University's Dwyer Arena. The 911 caller said that a 79-year-old male slipped on the ice at Dwyer Arena, slamming his head on the ice, and could not feel his extremeties. An ALS Priority response was recommended. No further information is available at this time. These are merely allegations and should not be taken as fact. LISTEN TO FULL AUDIO HERE: Promotional Content 79-year-old Suffers Head Injury After Falling on Ice at Niagara University

It was a cold and icy Christmas Eve in the picturesque town bordering the mighty Niagara Falls. People hustled about the small market square finishing up their Christmas shopping and adding finishing touches to their brightly decorated houses. The entire town sparkled with joyous holiday anticipation. Amongst the flurry of festivity lived the Turner family, known to everyone as the keepers of the famed Niagara Inn. Every year, they were in charge of organizing the grand Christmas celebration at the edge of the breathtaking Niagara Falls, which would culminate in the festive lighting of the grand, century-old evergreen tree overlooking the falls. But this Christmas was different. Mrs. Turner, the innkeeper and soul of all their grand events, fell sick just days before the celebration. Her loving husband and daughter, Alice, tried their best to pull together the party but everything seemed to go awry. To make matters worse, an snowstorm threatened to darken the grand celebration. Despite the troubles, Alice kept her faith. She could not let her mother or their town down. Early in the morning on Christmas Eve, she left home determined to save the holiday spirit. As she trudged through the deepening snow, she noticed the almost ethereal quiet around the Falls. She stood at the edge, whispering a small prayer for help. Suddenly, the winds changed direction. Alice noticed a glow dancing atop the turbulent waters of the Falls. To her surprise, it was a beautiful silver fir tree bobbing in the waters, mirroring their own evergreen Christmas tree. Without thinking twice, Alice extended her hand towards the water and in that moment, she felt a guiding force pulling her in the right direction. Soon enough, she had the fallen tree ashore and with the help of some kind neighbors, transported it to their event site. The townsfolk worked tirelessly, adorning it with twinkling fairy lights and vibrant baubles. Later that evening, as Alice flicked on the switch, the newly claimed tree bloomed into life. Gasps filled the chilly air as the town stood in awe, mesmerized by the spectacle before them. The reflection of the illuminated tree against the backdrop of the thundering Niagara Falls was a sight to behold. Just as the crowd erupted into applause, snow began to softly fall, covering everything in a beautiful white blanket. The imminent storm had turned into a beautiful White Christmas. And in the glow of the decorated tree, they could see Mrs. Turner, wrapped in a cozy quilt, smiling from their Inn's window. It was a Christmas miracle that the town would remember for years. And so, the story of Alice's brave feat spread across the town, warming hearts every Christmas season. The memory of the year Niagara Falls gifted them a tree became a beloved tale, filling everyone with faith in miracles and the magic of Christmas. Every year since, the town's Christmas tree would shimmer a little brighter, casting dancing reflections on the icy falls, reminding all of the true Christmas spirit. Promotional Content A Christmas Miracle in Niagara Falls

LISTEN TO POLICE AUDIO BELOW Law enforcement received a call around 1:25pm on December 20th after reports of an unwanted party on Cleveland Avenue in Niagara Falls. The 911 caller said that a male named "Jimmy" came over to help her with an appliance and was refusing to leave. The caller then told police that she had "many swords and knives" and would "use them if she had to." At the time of the call, the male party was still at her home. Police responded to the scene. No further information is available at this time. These are merely allegations and should not be taken as fact. LISTEN TO FULL AUDIO HERE: Promotional Content Woman with Samurai Swords Threatens Man who Won't Leave her Home in Niagara Falls

LISTEN TO POLICE AUDIO BELOW Law enforcement received a call around noon on December 21st after reports of a violent domestic altercation in Jordan Gardens in Niagara Falls near Highland Avenue. The 911 caller and victim stated that the suspect cut her arm and held a knife to her throat during a domestic incident. She then fled the apartment and walked to a nearby store where she called 911. At the time of the call, the suspect was still at the apartment. The suspect's name is included in the audio. Police responded to the scene. It is unknown if the suspect was arrested. No further information is available at this time. These are merely allegations and should not be taken as fact. LISTEN TO FULL AUDIO HERE: Promotional Content Suspect Holds Knife to Woman's Neck During Domestic Incident in Niagara Falls

LISTEN TO POLICE AUDIO BELOW Law enforcement received a call around 9pm on December 22nd after reports of a violent domestic incident on Roesch Avenue in Buffalo involving a tool. The 911 caller said that a female attacked him with a screwdriver. The female could be heard screaming at the male. The female hit him in the head and he was bleeding. At the time of the call, the caller was still with the suspect. Police responded to the scene. It is unknown if the suspect was arrested. No further information is available at this time. These are merely allegations and should not be taken as fact. LISTEN TO FULL AUDIO HERE: Promotional Content Crazed Woman Attacks Man with a Screwdriver Causing Severe Head Injury

Governor Kathy Hochul vetoed legislation advocates said was designed to preserve public and media access to police radio communications. Critics say the move undermines transparency and shields law enforcement activity from scrutiny. The bill, approved earlier this year by both the New York State Assembly and Senate, was crafted in response to a growing trend among police departments to fully encrypt their radio traffic. Legislators backing the measure said it was intended to protect the ability of journalists and first responders to receive timely information about public safety threats, monitor police activity as it unfolds, and hold officers accountable. Hochul rejected the measure late Friday night, issuing a veto message that questioned whether the bill’s safeguards for withholding “sensitive information” could realistically be implemented. She argued that separating routine police communications from sensitive material might not be technologically practical and warned of serious consequences if such information were made public. The governor said disclosure of certain details “could lead to loss of life or operational failure,” framing the veto as a public safety decision rather than a transparency issue. “While transparency is laudable, it should not come at the expense of public safety,” Hochul wrote in her veto message, adding that she did not believe a statewide mandate was necessary. She emphasized that local governments should retain control over how their police departments manage communications. “Municipalities remain free to make their own decisions as to whether to prohibit their police forces from encrypting radio transmissions,” Hochul wrote. Supporters of the legislation disagreed, arguing that expanded encryption makes it more difficult for journalists to alert the public to emergencies, assess police responses in real time, or investigate potential misconduct. Without access to radio transmissions, the public loses a critical window to know when crimes and/or other emergency operations are taking place, how law enforcement operates, or to hold them accountable when improper conduct takes place. Hochul also cited concerns about officer safety and the protection of elected officials, suggesting the bill could unintentionally expose undercover operations or sensitive movements. “In a time when public officials face growing threats of extreme violence, the bill also requires a police agency to effectively make real-time disclosure of the official’s movements to bloggers and paparazzi in addition to more traditional journalists,” said Hochul. The veto was one of nearly 50 issued by Hochul and released just before midnight Friday, a timing that drew additional criticism from advocates who say the administration routinely blocks transparency measures while offering little public debate. Promotional Content Hochul Doesn't Want You Listening in on Cops, Blocks Police Audio Transparency Bill

Our community is mourning the loss of Daniel Thompson III, a 6-year-old boy whose life was cut short after a battle with pneumonia. Daniel died on December 20th, 2025, leaving his family, classmates, and teammates devastated just days before Christmas. A 1st grader in Buffalo, Daniel was known for his warmth, curiosity, and gentle nature. Teachers and classmates alike described him as a joyful child who brought light into every room he entered. The news of Daniel’s passing was shared publicly by Amber Nicole, a teacher at his school, who posted a message on Facebook along with a link to a GoFundMe created to support the family during their loss. In her post, she wrote: “It is with the heaviest of hearts that I share this GoFundMe, Daniel was a sweet 6-year-old boy who attended my school. His mother, Jasmine, also works at my school and has become a dear friend to me and my family. Their family is facing the unimaginable right now. If you are able, please consider donating, sharing this page, or keeping them in your prayers as they navigate this incredibly difficult road ahead.” Outside the classroom, Daniel loved sports. He was a proud member of the Buffalo Vets youth football team and enjoyed basketball and soccer at home, often transforming his living room into a makeshift court or field. His imagination fueled hours of play with his older brother and cousins. Daniel’s life began by overcoming significant challenges. Born months prematurely, he spent an extended period hospitalized as a newborn. Despite those obstacles and ongoing respiratory issues, he persisted. After his passing, the Thompson family was faced with unexpected financial expenses. A GoFundMe page was created to assist with funeral and memorial costs, allowing the family to focus on grieving and honoring Daniel’s life. “Any contribution - big or small - is deeply appreciated. If you are unable to donate, please consider sharing this page and keeping the Thompson family in your thoughts and prayers. Thank you for helping us celebrate Daniel’s life and the light he brought into this world,” says the GoFundMe. Daniel’s father, Daniel Thompson, shared a personal message remembering his son’s spirit and their bond, writing: “To my big guy, biggest little man you’ll ever know, Loving, caring, kindest kid you’ll ever know. One of the most gentlest souls that ever blessed this earth. He would always say ‘papa, who got my back?’ I would say ‘I got your back’ And he would say ‘Let’s GOOOO!!!'” His mother, Maya, shared her grief in a brief but emotional message, writing: “My chunks. I’ll love you forever and always.” Friends, neighbors, teammates, and strangers across Buffalo have come together to support the Thompson family through prayers, donations, and messages of love. He is remembered not only for the battles he overcame, but for the joy, creativity, and kindness he shared in his short life. You can donate here: https://www.gofundme.com/f/honoring-daniel-thompson-iiis-memory/donate Promotional Content Community Mourns 6-year-old Who Dies Days Before Christmas

A scuffle at the Niagara Falls City Market on Saturday drew a law enforcement response after a bystander attempted to stop a shoplifting incident involving candy valued at less than $30. Niagara Falls Police officers said they were patrolling the market when they observed two men engaged in a physical altercation outside a business. At first, officers believed they were witnessing a robbery and immediately intervened, ordering both individuals to stop fighting. After separating the men, officers discovered several bags of Reese’s cups scattered on the ground near one of them. The man admitted to taking the candy from the store, telling officers. The other individual explained he had been inside the market and tried to prevent the theft before it escalated outside. While officers went inside the store to speak with employees, the man who attempted to stop the theft left the area and could not be located. The store’s assistant manager later told police the suspect entered the business around 5:30pm, grabbed multiple bags of candy with a total value of $28, and ran out. The assistant manager also indicated the suspect was known for repeatedly stealing from the store. Police charged the man with petit larceny and issued a trespass notice prohibiting him from returning to the location. He was released at the scene with an appearance ticket. Promotional Content Stranger Attacks Shoplifter Fleeing Store with $30 in Reeses Cups in Niagara Falls

Niagara County District Attorney Brian D. Seaman announced on Monday, December 22nd, an indictment was in Niagara County Court charging Richard J. Fox with one count of Murder in the Second Degree. Fox is charged with Murdering 32 year old Crystal Curthoys, formerly of Lockport, in January 2023, in Niagara Falls. Niagara Falls Police opened an investigation into Fox after he was charged with two murders in Erie County. The investigation led to the discovery this past March of human remains in a house where Fox had formerly lived in Niagara Falls. Those remains have been identified as belonging to Crystal Curthoys through dental records. Fox was remanded to jail without bail by County Court Judge John Ottaviano and a further court date was scheduled for January 5th, 2026. In March, authorities found the remains of an unidentified woman beneath a stairwell, enclosed in drywall, at a property on Orleans Avenue. The discovery came during a joint operation involving Niagara Falls Police detectives, Buffalo Police Homicide Squad officers, and investigators from the Chautauqua County Sheriff’s Office who were executing a search warrant at the location on March 28th. On April 8th, police ramped up their efforts by executing additional search warrants at multiple properties on Pierce, Pine, and LaSalle avenues. During the operation, authorities towed away a white Chevy Express utility van parked behind a residence on Pierce Avenue. The vehicle is believed to be linked to Fox and may play a role in the expanding investigation. On September 19th, Fox admitted that he murdered two other women whose remains were discovered together in Chautauqua County in September 2021, according to Erie County District Attorney Michael Keane. The victims, 50-year-old Marquita Mull and 40-year-old Cassandra Watson, had vanished from Buffalo nearly two decades apart. Investigators say Watson, who had been romantically involved with Fox, disappeared sometime between 2003 and 2004. Mull was last seen in July 2021. Their bodies were uncovered along a trail in the Town of Portland. Watson’s remains were located on September 26th, 2021, buried in a shallow grave. The following day, Mull’s remains were found less than 20 yards away. DNA testing later confirmed their identities. Authorities believe both women died by strangulation. Fox, now 62, pleaded guilty to two counts of second-degree murder. Prosecutors did not offer him a lesser plea. Promotional Content Richard Fox Charged with Murdering Woman in Niagara Falls, Concealing Body in Wall

The discovery of wooden “timeout” boxes inside two elementary schools in the Salmon River Central School District has prompted an intense statewide backlash, culminating in a call for immediate intervention from Governor Kathy Hochul. After photos of the enclosed wooden structures circulated on Facebook last week, the governor urged the state Education Department to move quickly, saying, “swift action to investigate and rectify this situation” was necessary. Hochul described the situation as deeply troubling, stating, “The reporting coming out of the Salmon River Central School District is highly disturbing and raises serious questions regarding the safety of children at this school.” She emphasized the responsibility schools have to protect children, adding, “As a mom, I know firsthand the trust parents place in our schools, and the teachers and administrators who work with our children. School should be a place where every child is safe, respected and supported.” However, Hochul could not explain how such conduct was permitted to occur undetected under her leadership. The wooden structures in question measured roughly five feet high and three feet wide. They were lined with padding inside. Although the district had never previously addressed their presence, administrators acknowledged earlier this week that the boxes had been located at two elementary schools. Parents later said that after speaking with their children, they believed some students — including autistic and non-verbal children — had been placed inside them. The district has since stated the boxes have been removed and dismantled. The state Education Department, which operates independently from the governor’s office, contacted Salmon River on Wednesday and ordered the district to immediately stop any practice that involved restraining or isolating students, including placing them in the boxes. A letter sent to the district said state officials would visit this week “to confirm the removal of all boxes,” and would return again “to ensure alternative calming spaces are identified for students that comply with state regulations.” Local law enforcement is also believed to be reviewing the matter. At least one parent has filed a criminal complaint. The district’s response has ignited the controversy further. School board members said they were unaware the boxes existed until photos spread online. The superintendent, Stanley Harper, originally acknowledged only one box and insisted it had never been used with students. During a school board meeting the following night, however, he conceded there were three and admitted he had learned about them only weeks earlier. That meeting drew an angry crowd demanding answers and accountability. For more than an hour, parents and community members described what their children had told them and recounted other alleged examples of mistreatment. The board placed Harper on “home duties” while an outside law firm conducts a review. The district's special education director, an elementary principal, and a teacher were also put on administrative leave. Remote learning was instituted Thursday and Friday “to ensure the safety of students and staff.” Classes are scheduled to resume in January. The demographic makeup of the district has heightened concerns. About 60 percent of students are Native American and one of the schools where the boxes were allegedly used is located on the St. Regis Mohawk Tribal Reservation. Speakers at the meeting said the images evoked historical trauma tied to the abuses inflicted at Native residential and day schools. In a statement, board president Jason Brockway said, “The Board of Education extends its sincere apology to our students, families, and community members who have been deeply affected by the ongoing situation. We understand that for many in our community this incident has reopened historical wounds and trauma connected to the mistreatment of Native (American) children. We hear you. We are humbled by the public response, and we feel the pain and fear expressed by our community.” The photos that ignited the investigation were posted by former board member Chrissy Jacobs who received them from another source. During the board meeting, she demanded consequences for anyone who authorized the boxes or failed to speak up, telling officials, “You treated our kids like animals.” New York regulations allow “timeout” only when children are placed in open, unlocked spaces where they can move, recline, and be visually monitored. Timeout can be used only as a last resort to prevent immediate harm or as a planned intervention outlined in a student’s behavior plan. The state explicitly bans “seclusion,” meaning the practice of placing a student alone in a locked or enclosed room. Promotional Content Hochul Scrambles After 'Timeout Box' Scandal Explodes in New York Schools

LISTEN TO POLICE AUDIO BELOW Law enforcement received a call around 8:45pm after reports of a domestic disturbance involving threats of physical injury to a child on the 400 block of 10th Street in Niagara Falls. The 911 caller - a woman - called twice. During the first call, she told police that her boyfriend was not welcome in the home and refused to leave. When she told him to do so, he allegedly threatened to shoot her child. The suspect is a white male named Chris Eoyrk. On the second call, she told police that her boyfriend was "shooting through her door with a 22-caliber" firearm. At that time, she barricaded herself in a second floor bedroom along with her child(ren). At the time of the call, the suspect was outside without a shirt one in below-freezing temperatures Police responded to the scene. It is unknown if the male was apprehended. No further information is available at this time. These are merely allegations and should not be taken as fact. LISTEN TO FULL AUDIO HERE: Promotional Content Boyfriend Threatens to Shoot Woman's Child, Starts Shooting Gun Through Front Door in Niagara Falls

LISTEN TO POLICE AUDIO BELOW Law enforcement received a call around 6pm on December 16th of menacing with a weapon at the Fashion Outlet Mall in Niagara Falls. The 911 caller said that a male was making general threats to a Spencer's worker. The male was descrbed as a white male. He was highly agitated. Security had eyes on the male. He was last seen at Auntie Anne's. It is unknown if he had bought a pretzel. It was then reported that the male had brandished a firearm during his altercation with the Spencer's employee. It was in his waistband. The official cause of said altercation has not been released by law enforcement. Police responded to the scene. It is unknown if the male was arrested. No further information is available at this time. These are merely allegations and should not be taken as fact. LISTEN TO FULL AUDIO HERE: Promotional Content Male Threatens Spencer's Employee with Gun During Possible Dildo Dispute in Niagara Falls

LISTEN TO POLICE AUDIO BELOW Law enforcement received around 6:30pm on December 17th after reports of breaking and entering on 20th Street in Niagara Falls. The 911 caller said that a male (named in the audio) broke into his ex-girlfriend's home. Upon entering, he threatened to kill people inside, including his ex-girlfriend, with a knife. According to sources, the male was reportedly heartbroken over the breakup. Police responded to the scene. It is unknown if the male was arrested. No further information is available at this time. These are merely allegations and should not be taken as fact. LISTEN TO FULL AUDIO HERE: Promotional Content Suspect Breaks Into Ex-girlfriend's Home, Starts Threatening to Kill People with Knife

LISTEN TO POLICE AUDIO BELOW Law enforcement received a call around 11am on December 16th after reports of an assault on the 1500 block of Pine Avenue in Niagara Falls. The 911 caller - a third party neighbor - stated that a neighbor is beating his elderly father. He could hear the noises made by the son as he hit his father in addition to the sounds made by the elderly male as he was being assaulted. At the time of the call, the beating was actively taking place. Police responded to the scene. It is unknown if the son was arrested. No further information is available at this time. These are merely allegations and should not be taken as fact. LISTEN TO FULL AUDIO HERE: Promotional Content Neighbor Calls Police as Son Starts Beating Elderly Father to Death in Niagara Falls

LISTEN TO POLICE AUDIO BELOW Law enforcement received a call around 5:15pm on December 13th after reports of a possible medical emergency on Pierce Avenue in Niagara Falls. The 911 caller said that a male was lying face down in the snow. There was also a mention that the incident was the result of a possible overdose. No update was given of the update of the male's condition. However, it was noted that the male was not moving. Police responded to the scene. It is unknown if the male was deceased. No further information is available at this time. These are merely allegations and should not be taken as fact. LISTEN TO FULL AUDIO HERE: Promotional Content Niagara Falls Police Discover Possible Dead Body Face Down in Snow

LISTEN TO POLICE AUDIO BELOW Law enforcement received a call around 9:15pm on December 10th after reports of an assault with a weapon that occurred at Hotel Cambria in Downtown Niagara Falls. The 911 caller stated that the male suspect was inside of the hotel. He came at her with brass knuckles and dropped his newborn baby on the ground. The suspect also has a knife. Police responded to the scene. It is unknown if the male was arrested. Unknown severity of injuries to the newborn baby. No further information is available at this time. These are merely allegations and should not be taken as fact. LISTEN TO FULL AUDIO HERE: Promotional Content Father Drops Newborn Child While Attacking Baby Momma With Brass Knuckles in Niagara Falls

LISTEN TO POLICE AUDIO BELOW Law enforcement received a call around 9pm on December 10th after reports of a shooting near Pine Avenue in Niagara Falls with injuries. The 911 caller stated that her daughter was shot and named the suspect. Police and medical responded to the scene. responded to the scene. It is unknown if the suspect was arrested. No further information is available at this time. These are merely allegations and should not be taken as fact. LISTEN TO FULL AUDIO HERE: Promotional Content Woman Calls 911 After Daughter was Shot in Niagara Falls

A tense standoff on 10th Street ended on Wednesday night with Niagara Falls Police taking a 29-year-old man into custody after reports that gunfire had been directed toward another person inside a home. Officers were first called to a residence on the 400 block of 10th Street at about 8:45pm for a complaint involving an unwanted individual. The situation escalated when dispatchers were told that a man had fired a .22-caliber firearm through a door. According to police, the shot was aimed toward someone on the other side. Fortunately, the individual was not struck. When officers arrived, they immediately secured the area and set up a perimeter after receiving information that the suspect was still inside the home. Police used loudspeaker announcements to direct anyone inside to exit. Five people eventually came out, all of whom complied with officers’ commands. Investigators later confirmed that none of them were the suspect. With the man believed to be barricaded in the house, police continued issuing commands over the patrol vehicle’s loudspeaker. However, the man ignored them. The Niagara Falls Police Department’s Emergency Response Team and Crisis Negotiation Team were then deployed to the scene. The standoff concluded when the Emergency Response Team entered the home and found the suspect on an upper floor. He was taken into custody without further confrontation. Detectives recovered two long guns and additional evidence from the residence. The Criminal Investigation Division is continuing to review the case and charges are expected to be filed. Promotional Content Armed Standoff Ends with SWAT Team Storming Home in Niagara Falls

New York State Police reported an arrest for driving while intoxicated that occurred on Thursday, December 11th, in Lewiston involving a Niagara Falls School teacher. Victoria Waugaman, 28-years-old, was arrested around 11pm after colliding with an unoccupied vehicle on Center Street. The impact caused significant damage to the vehicle. It is unknown if Waugaman sustained any injuries in the accident. Arrest information released by the New York State Police Waugaman reportedly failed standardized field sobriety testing and had a BAC far exceeding .08%. No further information is available at this time. Promotional Content Niagara Falls School Teacher Victoria Waugaman Arrested for DWI

LISTEN TO POLICE AUDIO BELOW Law enforcement received a 911 call on December 12th after a witness described watching an individual go over Niagara Falls. Law enforcement responded to the welcome center. The witness described watching someone go over Niagara Falls, believed to be a male. However, it could have been a female. The witness described seeing the individual in the water from the Prospect Point Observation Tower. Several first responders went to the location. The result of the call is unknown, including if a body was recovered. As we have previously reported, dozens of individuals go over Niagara Falls each year that never are reported on. This is a fact. Some bodies are never located while others surface at the Power Authority or along Lake Ontario. No further information is available at this time. These are merely allegations and should not be taken as fact. LISTEN TO FULL AUDIO HERE: Promotional Content Witness Watches Man Go Over Niagara Falls

Niagara Action previously reported on Michael Collesano, a Manhattan-based attorney and real estate broker, who filed a defamation lawsuit against a neighbor for comments allegedly made about his small manhood. The lawsuit, filed on May 11th, 2025, in New York County Supreme Court, has gained traction in recent months with all parties having filed answers and requests for subpoenas . Collesano alleged that Aimee Fink, a neighbor in his condominium complex, launched a campaign to damage his professional reputation and business. The verified complaint chronicled what Collesano described as months of harassment tied to a contentious board election at the Warren House condominium and accused Fink of making defamatory statements, interfering with his business dealings, and disparaging him personally and professionally. However, the heart of his lawsuit centers around a comment levied on January 17th, 2025, where Fink allegedly motioned with her fingers to indicate something small and shouted: “you have a little dick.” A comment that will now live forever in court filings . . . . Niagara Action has not independently verified the claims made in this lawsuit and presents them solely as allegations, which remain unproven unless and until established in court. Collesano claims the insult was made publicly, witnessed by building staff, and illustrative of a broader campaign of harassment. Two weeks after the January lobby incident, Collesano says he told Fink he intended to sue her. According to the filing, she responded by thrusting her middle finger in his face and calling police. The episode generated an NYPD report but no criminal charges. The lawsuit prompted us to ask the question, will Collesano likely be successful in his defamation lawsuit against Fink? We uploaded Collesano's Complaint and asked Chat GPT — this is what it said: Will the lawsuit for defamation brought by Attorney Michael Collesano against Aimee Fink for a comment alleging that he has “a little dick” be successful? To put it plainly: almost certainly not. And New York case law makes that conclusion all but inevitable. According to the verified complaint filed by Michael Collesano, he alleges that during a January 17, 2025 interaction outside his condominium, Aimee Fink “motioned with her fingers indicating a small distance and screamed at him, ‘you have a little dick.’” This isolated insult—undeniably crude, juvenile, and hostile—forms part of his defamation count. But in New York, words being mean is not the same thing as words being defamatory, and courts have repeated this principle for decades. Defamation requires a false assertion of fact, not a moment of playground-style name-calling. New York courts explicitly hold that “statements that are merely abusive, annoying, or embarrassing are not actionable” because they lack the factual content required to be defamatory. 1. The Threshold Problem: It’s Not a “Fact”—It’s an Insult Under New York law, a statement is only defamatory if (1) it is capable of being proven true or false, and (2) a reasonable listener would understand it as conveying actual fact. Courts routinely dismiss suits over insults, epithets, or obvious hyperbole because they are not factual assertions at all. Calling someone a vulgar name—even a sexually demeaning one—falls squarely into the category of nonactionable opinion or rhetorical hyperbole. New York’s Court of Appeals has held repeatedly that “[l]oose, figurative, or hyperbolic statements, even if deprecating, are not actionable because they cannot be proven true or false.” When a neighbor in a heated interpersonal conflict yells a sexual insult, no reasonable person interprets that as a literal medical or anatomical measurement. It is understood universally as an expression of disdain—not as a factual representation of physical traits. Courts know this, and they reject similar claims as a matter of law. 2. The “Truth Is a Defense” Principle Only Underscores the Problem for the Plaintiff New York law makes truth an absolute defense to defamation—and, importantly, the defendant does not need to prove truth unless the statement is the kind that is capable of being true or false in the first place. Here, the comment is so plainly an insult rather than an empirical claim that courts would not even reach the truth inquiry. The statement’s very nature keeps it out of defamation territory. But if it were treated as “factual,” the plaintiff would face another challenge: he would be litigating the size of his own penis in public court. Legal commentators note that plaintiffs who bring lawsuits over insults like this “open the door” to discovery and proof on the very subject they say is defamatory. The fact that this lawsuit invites that possibility only amplifies how unserious the claim appears—and how unlikely it is that any court would permit it to move forward. 3. Context Matters—and the Complaint’s Own Facts Undermine the Claim The setting, as pleaded, is a personal dispute between co-residents of a building, escalating over assessments, board disagreements, and interpersonal hostility. The complaint itself describes months of conflict, accusations, and bad blood between the parties. The January 17 exchange occurs in that broader emotional context—not in a professional setting, not in public media, and not in a situation where reasonable observers would treat the insult as conveying factual information. New York courts emphasize that context determines meaning. In a heated argument, sexual insults are understood as exactly that: insults. Not defamation. 4. New York Requires Defamation Per Se to Be About Profession—Not Anatomy Collesano, who is both a real estate broker and an attorney, frames the lawsuit as one that injures his professional reputation. But New York defamation-per-se doctrine only applies when the statement: accuses the plaintiff of a serious crime, alleges he has a disease, impugns his profession, or implies unchastity (historically applied to women). A remark about genital size has nothing to do with lawyering, real-estate brokerage, or any professional capacity. There is no rule of professional conduct for attorneys or brokers that governs sexual insults or anatomical references. No reasonable reader or listener would conclude that, because someone shouted an obscene remark outside an apartment building, the plaintiff is unfit to practice law. Put differently: even if everything the complaint alleges is true, New York law simply does not recognize “has a small penis” as a professional allegation. 5. The Complaint’s Tone and Scope Create a Serious Proportionality Issue Courts also look at proportionality. When a plaintiff seeks judicial intervention over trivial or childish insults, especially in interpersonal disputes, judges often dismiss the action early to avoid turning courts into referees of neighborhood quarrels. Here, the complaint spans 20 pages and details years of disputes, board politics, emails, elevator conversations, and personal dislike—culminating in a single crude insult shouted during a building disagreement. The sheer mismatch between the legal claim and the conduct alleged highlights why courts treat these suits skeptically. Put straightforwardly: New York defamation law is not designed to adjudicate playground-level personal attacks between neighbors. 6. Bottom Line: This Lawsuit Is Not Likely to Succeed Under New York Law When the elements of defamation are matched against the allegation, the result is legally clear: The statement is not a factual assertion. It is crude hyperbole, not defamation. The context shows it was an insult during a dispute, not a published assertion of fact. It does not relate to the plaintiff’s profession and is not defamation per se. New York courts routinely dismiss similar claims at the pleadings stage. In short: the lawsuit is overwhelmingly unlikely to succeed, and the claim itself borders on frivolous under established New York precedent. BELOW IS A COPY OF THE COMPLAINT: Promotional Content Will Michael Collesano Win Suit Over Tiny Genitals Comment? Chat GPT Says 'Certainly Not'